Image
Interordi Menu
Inactive
428 posts
Quote

it\'s alright anyway in short great comic wouldn\'t change a thing and can\'t wait for the next one

Maneko
Lil' metool
Inactive
11 posts
Quote

Well! What\'s up with Mal\'s apparent obession with testicles?
And how in the hell this comic can be \"gay\"?

You know, after reading this...

Quote:
Originally posted by Mal
MAL\'S CRITIQUE
*snip* (Insert a scary discussion about testicles here) *snip* her sons can\'t manage to swallow something that large without having the constitution of Jenna Jameson.
*snip again*
That\'s the problem with this comic. It\'s generic and boring (and difficult to swallow).


Testicles, difficult to swallow, and finding gay references in everything... mal, are you gay, by any chance?
Not trying to flame or nothing, but this simply CAN\'T be a coincidance.

Finally, if you are going to send a crap avalanche against other people\'s work, maybe you should check this link before...
http://www.neomonsterisland.com/a_archives/019/918/1.html
I think it sums my point, eh? Yeah, I know.

Rioni Riishu
Superstar!
Inactive
729 posts
Quote

There\'s critique, and there\'s flaming... Mal seems... dangerously close to a flame. Normally, you would state what\'s good about something along with what\'s bad. It does leave me to wonder, though- Mal seems to think the comic is so \"bad,\" but in general, it\'s pretty popular, it seems. Frankly, it doesn\'t matter what you draw or how you draw it, someone will find it unappealing. But note to you people who do- Just because you don\'t like it doesn\'t mean it sucks. I hate Naruto and Battle Network. Does it mean they suck? Of course not. It just means I don\'t like them. It\'s selfish and egostical to think that your opinion is the only one that has weight.

-Also, I don\'t find Megatokyo\'s art appealing. I like Iris\' style for this because it\'s reminiscent of official Megaman style. I think it stands out just fine, and I think I\'d be able to pick it out from other artists.

I enjoy your work, Iris. Of course it\'s not perfect. Nothing ever is. But sometimes things are more fun when they\'re not perfect. And heck, it\'s always fun to look back and see your own improvement.

-Ri

The Helldragon
Inquisitor of Zork
Inactive
-3279 post
Princess Celestia
Princess Celestia
Got all items in the AFD2012 event!
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Lilly Satou
Lilly Satou
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Emi Ibarazaki
Emi Ibarazaki
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Rin Tezuka
Rin Tezuka
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Hanako Ikezawa
Hanako Ikezawa
Acquired on 1 April 2012

... and 18 more
Quote

You know, once in class I wrote about an idiot-vampire who absorbed the energy of stupid people and their mindless chattering in order to become more powerful. It seems his influence should be felt here.

You see my above statement? That, people, is something that has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH MY ARGUMENT. And you know, Mal, or son, or whatever name I\'m gonna give ya, you try to remain focused when you\'re complaining about someone\'s work. Do we want to hear about your mother and her shaved...ahem, private areas that the good Doctor removed for the benefit of our children? Why, no, we don\'t! Do remember that when we read an argument for or against someone\'s work, we expect coherence (which you thankfully managed) and focus (which you killed our rainbows because of it). Perhaps you would be willing to try again, maybe on a lesser known webcomic? I hear practice is good for building confidence in such matters.

News flash-Megatokyo SUCKS.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Quote:
Originally posted by The Helldragon
You know, once in class I wrote about an idiot-vampire who absorbed the energy of stupid people and their mindless chattering in order to become more powerful. It seems his influence should be felt here.

You see my above statement? That, people, is something that has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH MY ARGUMENT. And you know, Mal, or son, or whatever name I\'m gonna give ya, you try to remain focused when you\'re complaining about someone\'s work. Do we want to hear about your mother and her shaved...ahem, private areas that the good Doctor removed for the benefit of our children? Why, no, we don\'t! Do remember that when we read an argument for or against someone\'s work, we expect coherence (which you thankfully managed) and focus (which you killed our rainbows because of it). Perhaps you would be willing to try again, maybe on a lesser known webcomic? I hear practice is good for building confidence in such matters.

News flash-Megatokyo SUCKS.

And thus I am awarded again with a first word. ;P But thank you for the support.

Mal
Banned
3 posts
Quote

Alright, a couple more points before I vanish into the wild blue.

Believe it or not, I\'m not gay, and I\'m surprised my sexual preference has even been brought up.

Say what you like about MT (I know it seems rather trendy to dislike it these days) but the man knows how to draw, he knows how to present himself to the world, and hey, at the end of the day he\'s supporting his family through his art. He\'s published three books, with a fourth on the way. Hell, the guy\'s been signed by DC. That\'s success.

Interestingly enough, the \'Megaman style\' already has a name. That name is \'Manga\' and it has been around for a lot longer than Capcom of for that matter the video game industry itself.

Finally, Rioni (I think that was the name - female sounding Japanese-type name) made some interesting and very flawed points. I never said the thing sucked - I made a critique. You connotated that I believe it sucks, which isn\'t true. I won\'t be reading it in the future, but that\'s my choice and my opinion, which is after all what the author asked for with this topic. It\'s pretty funny to think that you\'re accusing me of doing exactly the same thing you\'re actually doing - \'I disagree with Mal therefore Mal\'s opinion is wrong\'. It\'s an opinion, champ, not a statement of fact. Art\'s a very relative medium, and one man\'s garbage is another man\'s \'great comic\'.

You also asked if I had anything good to say about the comic, and I neglected to mention how much I approved of the website\'s design. Because my Firefox is kind enough to block most java, I was unable to scroll through the archives without removing the block on the offending website (something I was particularly loathe to do as I was afraid of Trojans and Mongols that day), meaning I was thankfully not exposed to overly much of the comic.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Quote:
Originally posted by Mal
Alright, a couple more points before I vanish into the wild blue.

Believe it or not, I\'m not gay, and I\'m surprised my sexual preference has even been brought up.

Say what you like about MT (I know it seems rather trendy to dislike it these days) but the man knows how to draw, he knows how to present himself to the world, and hey, at the end of the day he\'s supporting his family through his art. He\'s published three books, with a fourth on the way. Hell, the guy\'s been signed by DC. That\'s success.

Interestingly enough, the \'Megaman style\' already has a name. That name is \'Manga\' and it has been around for a lot longer than Capcom of for that matter the video game industry itself.

Finally, Rioni (I think that was the name - female sounding Japanese-type name) made some interesting and very flawed points. I never said the thing sucked - I made a critique. You connotated that I believe it sucks, which isn\'t true. I won\'t be reading it in the future, but that\'s my choice and my opinion, which is after all what the author asked for with this topic. It\'s pretty funny to think that you\'re accusing me of doing exactly the same thing you\'re actually doing - \'I disagree with Mal therefore Mal\'s opinion is wrong\'. It\'s an opinion, champ, not a statement of fact. Art\'s a very relative medium, and one man\'s garbage is another man\'s \'great comic\'.

You also asked if I had anything good to say about the comic, and I neglected to mention how much I approved of the website\'s design. Because my Firefox is kind enough to block most java, I was unable to scroll through the archives without removing the block on the offending website (something I was particularly loathe to do as I was afraid of Trojans and Mongols that day), meaning I was thankfully not exposed to overly much of the comic.


I guess the overall problem was more with the LANGUAGE you used for your review. (And your strange fixation with male private parts and drugs. There\'s more about testicles than there is about the actual comic...) There\'s a way to be reviewing something in a classy way, you know. By the way, if you had a problem with the java, I could have easily given you a way to review the whole thing. It\'s strange that you are the only one (Out of about 1200 readers from the Megaman community) that has problems with my java.

I\'m not hurt that you don\'t like it, of course. :P Everyone\'s entitled to their own opinion and you\'re not the first one.

...Some people even like Megatokyo.

[Edited on 9-3-2006 by Iris]

[Edited on 9-3-2006 by Iris]

PsychoGiga
Village Idiot
Inactive
534 posts
Quote

From what I read it sounds like you think it sucks. But whatever, that\'s yer opinion, as already stated. I think that the art itself is fine, I wouldn\'t change anything about it. Some of the jokes were pretty good, especially when Bass was trying to get his remote back from the women.:lol: Somehow, though, I think it is more perverted than it is funny. And I\'m surprised to see such perversion come from a woman, especially since it\'s the guys in the comic who are the pervs. That\'s your choice, though. I haven\'t read a lot of comics, but Penny Arcade and VG Cats are good. I think it is dumb to compare them to Iris\', though, since her comic is much different. She stays on a set theme, whereas they do paradies and make fun of different games.


"A closed mouth gathers no foot" -This is a fact of life, and I don't know who said it.

94% of all teenagers have tried drugs at one time or another. If you are one of the 6% that haven't, put this message in your signature.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Now that\'s one thing. This is a Megaman comic. Why would I draw it in any other way than how Capcom draw their stuff?

This is also not a professional comic. It\'s a FAN...WORK. I don\'t strive to be a cartoonist. I\'m just a Megaman fan that happens to know how to draw. (And would rather not waste her time on recoloring sprites and paste them on a cheap background)

But what really boggles me is: why did you come here just for that? It\'s a very interesting fact! I mean, there is much more other places you could\'ve contacted me. Bob and George, email, blog, or my own forums... How peculiar that you come to a forums I have been on only for a few days just to review your dislike of my comic!

I\'m charmed, to say the least.

Necro
Hail to the King, baby!
Inactive
1265 posts
Quote

I\'ve read up to about the 1000 hits comic and two of the newer ones. I kinda like the art in the older ones more so than the newer. Maybe it\'s just because it\'s the Battle Network characters but I don\'t like the skinnier proportions as much. Not that it\'s really worse, it just looks less appealing to me. But that\'s just me. :)

I didn\'t really find any of the jokes(from the ones I did read) funny really. Some were kinda cute but they didn\'t make me laugh. But I have abit of a twisted sense of humour.


Mr.Mettaur
Superstar!
Offline
1332 posts
Quote

The artwork really does combine itself with the humor. Even if the joke is a cliche, if the drawing to go along with it is amusing, I find it just as funny.

My absolute favorite thing in this comic would have to be everyone\'s facial expressions on the first panel of the comic where Bass exposes his hair.

Thiyr
Lil' metool
Inactive
2 posts
Quote

Yea, i only knew about these forums FROM Stage Select, so i felt it was my duty as an overall forum-whore to make one post here in the thread that lead to this discovery, if not for any reason other than for shits and giggles. I could have done this in other places, but i am too damn lazy to find them, so HERE IT GOES! HOORAY!

Pros of Stage Select: It makes me laugh, sometimes in a very \"lawl\" fashion.
The art is great.
It is a fresh spin on the extremely tired megaman comic.
It is not another bob and george ripoff, which makes me happy. At least she has some originality <:

Cons: It comes out twice weekly. I need more stage-select brand addictive substance.(No, this isn\'t asking for more/faster updates, cause that would probably overwork the Iris and give us all a shittier product.
You\'ve been stuck on the time-travel/battle network thing since the start. I figure it will be ending soon, meaning fresh setting, meaning more opportunities for more \"lawling\".

In other words, keep doing what you are doing, and get a bigger stick to beat off rabid fans and stupid idiots with.

pual
White Shade
Inactive
243 posts
Quote

Quote:
Originally posted by BladeMan.EXE
From the looks of things from a Google image search, Sailor Galaxia was a character in one of the Sailor Moon movies, which one I\'m not quite sure.

Anyways, a funny comic as always. I await the next one patiently.

actually she is part of the sailor stars collection.
but yes I enjoyed comic as well.


^Died thinking that he was the lord of caocs when he is the lord of care bears.- Ringman
with corrections to spelling..
< died thinking he was lord of chaos when he is lord of the care bears. Ringman

‎"those who live by sword get shot by those who live by gun....who get imprisoned by those who live by the law...Who get killed by those who live by the sword."
GYAAAH!!! ITS A VICIOUS CYCLE!!!

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

And thus, after a good cold that stopped me from updating on my normal schedule (Pretty much seems as if I skipped one, literally. But I\'ll post a new one tomorrow too to make up for it), I have just posted a new comic.
Go view it. :)

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Aaaaaand posted the last of the delayed comics today! If you got any comments and criticism (or reviews! But please, try to actually review the comic and not something about your nurse mom. :P), I\'d be glad to hear it. ;)
http://www.stage-select.com

Banned
252 posts
Quote

lol,what post is this?i don know this but you talking about megaman x stage select?

The Helldragon
Inquisitor of Zork
Inactive
-3279 post
Princess Celestia
Princess Celestia
Got all items in the AFD2012 event!
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Lilly Satou
Lilly Satou
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Emi Ibarazaki
Emi Ibarazaki
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Rin Tezuka
Rin Tezuka
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Hanako Ikezawa
Hanako Ikezawa
Acquired on 1 April 2012

... and 18 more
Quote

Bass is God of the Burn. Nuff said.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Quote:
Originally posted by megaman x rocks!
lol,what post is this?i don know this but you talking about megaman x stage select?


....What? Megaman X stage select? o_o I\'m lost.

Mr.Mettaur
Superstar!
Offline
1332 posts
Quote

Maybe he\'s talking about
Down Time: When Master Attack. XD

I think he got the (sub)titles mixed up.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

I...see... O_o;;;;;;

Hardman
Dragoon Paladin
Inactive
449 posts
Quote

Finally! A MM comic drawn!


Yes, THAT Hardman. This is the new and improved one.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Well, since I\'m back at lurking around here, I guess I can announce that I have posted a new update.

Recently, things went back to the original 20XX. :)

http://www.stage-select.com

Mr.Mettaur
Superstar!
Offline
1332 posts
Quote

Aha, now I can start reading it again.

I stopped, you see. Because Firefox updated and I lost my bookmarks. And I'm really really lazy to the point that I didn't replace half of them.

Anywho, keep it up. :D

The Helldragon
Inquisitor of Zork
Inactive
-3279 post
Princess Celestia
Princess Celestia
Got all items in the AFD2012 event!
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Lilly Satou
Lilly Satou
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Emi Ibarazaki
Emi Ibarazaki
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Rin Tezuka
Rin Tezuka
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Hanako Ikezawa
Hanako Ikezawa
Acquired on 1 April 2012

... and 18 more
Quote

Firefox did that to me too! That's why I haven't replaced them eiter.

Juno
I AM the Iron Pony!!
Inactive
-1485 post
Rainbow Dash
Rainbow Dash
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Derpy Hooves
Derpy Hooves
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Fluttershy
Fluttershy
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Pinkie Pie
Pinkie Pie
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Princess Celestia
Princess Celestia
Got all items in the AFD2012 event!
Acquired on 1 April 2012

... and 18 more
Quote

Loved the recent comics :) You should really think about doing more in color.

So Iris, what are your plans for Forte once he returns?




~Juno~


Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

Quote:
Originally posted by Juno
Loved the recent comics :) You should really think about doing more in color.


The problem with that is that yes ,they are prettier... But it takes way longer too. :P And now that I have a job, I can't quite afford it.

Quote:
So Iris, what are your plans for Forte once he returns?




~Juno~


I can't spoil that! :P You'll have to wait.

Edited by Iris on May 17, 2006 at 14:39:04.

Edited by Iris on May 17, 2006 at 14:39:32.

Juno
I AM the Iron Pony!!
Inactive
-1485 post
Rainbow Dash
Rainbow Dash
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Derpy Hooves
Derpy Hooves
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Fluttershy
Fluttershy
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Pinkie Pie
Pinkie Pie
Acquired on 1 April 2012
Princess Celestia
Princess Celestia
Got all items in the AFD2012 event!
Acquired on 1 April 2012

... and 18 more
Quote

I was afraid you would say that :(
Well, looking foward to the next updates ^_^




~Juno~


Morphman
Niz-Da
Offline
2647 posts
Quote

Ah, the coloured one owned me eyeballs. Ouchies. So good. Looking forward to the upcoming comics.

Edited by Morphman on May 17, 2006 at 16:46:00.


Image
All hail the Supreme Comrade Cossack!

FlareMan
DMN #007
Inactive
1175 posts
Quote

Quote:
Originally posted by Iris
EDIT: Since HollowTorment greatly suggested this to me, I'd like to state that this thread is for FEEDBACK. Please do not spam it with just "lol" or "Say wha?! Sailor Moon! Hahaha! XD :rofl:" As I said in the PREVIOUS thread, this is not my goal. And I find that EXTREMELY insipid.

Please try to post more content that can be of use to me.

And don't I just LOVE being insipid? :P

OMGSAILORMOONLOLROFL :dieslaughteryay:

My point is basically just don't be picky about your audience. I would personally be glad to have one at all.

However, I *would* kindly mention that normal forum rules apply, and spam-posts like "lol" and such are permitted in the thread as much as anywhere else on the forum. (Meaning NOT.)


Back from another thousand-year hibernation.

Iris
Robot master
Inactive
66 posts
Quote

What can I say? I like having posts with meat around the bone. :P Say what you like, say what you don't like. I'm open to every feedback.

BTW, I posted a new comic.