I like CS(cell shaded) games cuz they give a colorful and toony style to the game.

Post redacted

Shuffle was an early example of celshading, I\'m sure they could do a much better job with a celshaded Sonic today.

As for the question being asked, I don\'t really care about graphics enough to care about celshading. As long as celshading can fit the nature of the game and is well done, it\'s welcome by me by all means. I think the most important factor on whether or not it\'s a good or bad thing depends on the game itself. For example, sports games should shy away from trying anything like that and try to remain as realistic looking as possible, in my opinion. I\'m sorry if anyone disagrees but I don\'t want to be playing a sports game that looks like a cartoon.

Has anybody played XIII? That\'s an awesome game. Cell shaded FPS, sweet.:D

I kind of prefer the old look. Ocarina was better than Wind Waker IMO

That\'s trolling:P

Same here. They should have stuck with the 64 look. Wind waker wasn\'t all bad, but Ocarina & Majora leave it in the dust.

Jet Set Radio, First game to use it and still looks better than quite afew newer games.

The best use of Cell Shading IMO is Robotech: Battlecry...As for Wind Waker, Nintendo should\'ve used the 64 looks...

Tey Battlecry was an awsome CS game.*cries*

I love CS, but old style graphics are better. I love Jet Set Radio Future graphics.

No, I stated that it was my opinion, which cannot be grounds for trolling. So there

PWNED!

Yeah,yis okay,Side scrolling+cell shading in my opinion though is evil((MMNT.Good game,bad graphics)And Windwaker....Link looked evil.His head was twice the size of his body!XD

Monster Rancher 3 rules!
*looks both ways*
What? It was cel shaded!

Cel shaded games RULE!!!

i can dig some cel shaded games.... but now their starting to make too many

Actually, I think the first game to use it was Metal Gear Solid: VR Missions, in the intro. I know I sound nuts, but I\'m pretty sure...

Anyway, I don\'t really care about cel-shading, though it\'s already easy to create cartoony characters with 3D graphics (Luigi\'s Mansion probably has the best cartoony look in a game to date, in my opinion, and it used full 3D. Mario Sunshine\'s another example.). I thought the cel-shading in Wind Waker was very good, though. And the head was supposed to be bigger than the body. It\'s called chibi.

1st off wind waker is like the 1st game that they really tryed useing cell shadeing and becuse its a 1st i think of wind waker more as as a practice for cell shadeing then like a game even tho i did really like it i think it was kewl looking for a 1st and any way i think nintendo was going to do cell shadeing becuse everyone was trying to aim for real looking stuff so nintendo went the uther way and did cell shadeing something like that anyway mmt was the next with cell shadeing and it looked 10 times better so i realy think there just practiceing right now with cell shadeing i think its going to end up looking realy cool il be looking forward to it

Hmmm...The last time I checked, Robotech: Battlecry came before and it was CellShaded...

im just saying for nintendo

Oh, my bad.

personally i think anime based games look alot better cell-shaded, seeing as it goes with the bright shiny things that tend to show up. Take Dragonball Z budokai for example, it was kinda bland looking in the PS2 version, but in the GC version it looked alot like the anime, And alot more clean. I think GC has a better cellshading option then PS2 because DBZB 2 Was cellshaded and came out looking kinda weird.

[Edited on 3-2-2004 by Master_Tiger]

i think cell shadeing is going to rox very soon i hope anyway

Anime based games usually ROCK when Cell shading is used for the game.

But then again, it mostly depends on the gameplay/story to make it successful. Something that many gamedesigners seem to have forgotten as of late.... Just eye candy......... too bad, though

At the moment, i\'m pretty sure that the cell shading we know is at a basic point. I believe that there will be a game that will take this graphic style to a next level somewhere this year >_>

X.