Image
Interordi Menu
Mega X.exe
Forum Ghost
Offline
6444 posts
Quote

The question, "Must a relativistic ethic replace an absolutist ethic?" is reviewed.

Douglas Templemore killed his child with a shot of strychinine chlorhydrate; and then called a physician to certify that the child was dead. After he had been informed of the circumstances, the perplexed Dr. Figgins notified a homocide inspector. In interviewing Mr. Templemore the inspector asked to speak to the mother, and the following conversation ensued.

"I'm afraid you are under a misapprehension," said Douglas. "The child is not hers."

"Oh... uh... well... is the-er-the mother here, then?"

"No," said Templemore.

"Ah... where is she?"

"She was taken back to the zoo yesterday."

"The zoo? Does she work there?"

"No. She lives there."

"I beg your pardon?"

"The mother," said Templemore, "is not a woman, properly speaking. She is a female of the species Paranthropus erectus."


With this revelation, Dr. Figgins then examined the body more closely and declared it to be a monkey, not a boy. In response, Templemore produced an affidavit that explained the “child” was produced by the artificial insemination of a female ape, named Derry, species Paranthropus erectus with the donor being Douglas M. Templemore.

In the following exchange, Templemore insists that the inspector treat this as a murder.

”I have killed my child, Inspector”

“I’ve grasped that. But this… this creature isn’t a… it doesn’t present…”

“He’s been christened, Inspector, and his birth duly entered at the registry office under the name of Garry Ralph Templemore.”

“Under what name was the mother entered.”
“Under her own, Inspector. ‘Native woman from New Guinea, known as Derry.”

“False declaration!” cried the inspector triumphantly.

“The whole registration is invalid.”

“The mother isn’t a woman.”

“That remains to be proved.”

“Why, you yourself…”

“Opinions are divided.”

“Divided? Divided about what? Whose opinions?”

“Those of the leading anthropologists, about the species the Paranthropus belongs to. It’s an intermediate species: Man or ape? It may well be that Derry is a woman after all. It’s up to you to prove the contrary if you can. In the meantime, heer child is my son, before God and the law.”



This provocative discussion and the circumstances that gave rise to it are taking from the opening scene of a novel by Vercors entitled, You Shall Know Them. The book describes the experiences of Douglas Templemore during a series of trials to determine whether or not he was guilty of infanticide. Scientists, philosophers, and theologians attempt to establish a criterion for determining whether the Paranthropus erectus is human is, or is not, human.

Ethics can be properly understood only in the light of the value placed upon the human species. Throughout history, differential treatment of man* and animals has been justified as an appeal to the difference in kind between the two.

In our day, the nature of the distinction between human and animal is often debated. According to evolutionary doctrine, we have come up through the animal world; hence we differ from animals in degree (e.g., humans are generally more intelligent), but not in kind (humans and animals are not fundamentally different). Behaviorism links humans with animals by insisting that both are products of either heredity or environment. The behaviorist explains that both are totally explicable in terms of matter: that is, the human being does not possess an immaterial soul or spirit.

The closer we view ourselves as linked to the animal world, the more difficult it becomes to hold out for a distinctly human dignity, for the traditional respect that has been given to human life. Without adequate respect for human life, moral absolutes must disintegrate. A relativistic approach is a logical result. This aim of developing a relativistic ethic does, of course, correspond with the abandonment of the distinction in kind between man and animal.

“Hardly anyone under thirty believes your view anymore,” a teenager tells her parents. And, in part, she speaks the truth. No one can deny that moral valuations are changing. One of the most obvious changes in moral standards has occurred in the area of human sexuality. Pornography is readily available today to almost anyone, even the very young. Contraceptives can be easily purchases, and books describe in great detail the “proper” procedures for multiple sexual encounters. The movie industry has discovered that films banned ten years ago because they were considered obscene are now eagerly accepted and only a few churches are complaining.

Changes are also seen in a multitude of other moral issues. In the past, moral principles were frequently instilled by calling attention to the penalty involved if the moral code were violated. We’ve all heard that “honesty is the best policy.” Yet today it is not repeated very often. Why? One reason is that many people realize that it is not always prudent to be honest (at least it may not be to their advantage financially). Frequently the crook becomes wealthy; the honest person remains poor. This causes many of us to ask, “If it doesn’t pay to be honest, why bother?” That is an excellent question, and behind it is the problem of finding a criterion by which actions must be judged.

How then shall we decide whether changes in the moral climate are a sign of progress or an indication of moral regression? In other words, how can we decide which actions are morally right and which are morally wrong? Our immediate reaction might be to begin to debate the whole range of moral issues, to make a long list of such issues and discuss the pros and cons of each one. But, unfortunately, such a procedure would have little chance of success. We would soon discover that unless we have some agreement as to what kind of value system we wish to adopt, we cannot even begin to distinguish the pros from the cons.

We must be willing to set aside temporarily the question of what actions are right or wrong to focus on a more basic question: What makes an action right or wrong? If we can establish a basic moral criterion, then we might be able to reach an agreement on diverse moral issues. Whether abortion, mate-swapping, euthanasia, or capital punishment are right or wrong depends on the standard, the basic norm by which actions are judged. In this book, we will discuss this problem. Specifically, we are seeking to answer a basic moral question: By what yardstick ought we to judge whether an act is moral or immoral?

We may indeed wonder whether Douglas Templeton was guilty of infanticide, but an even more basic question is whether infanticide itself should be considered evil. Without some moral standard, not even such a basic question as this can be answered. The following chapters will examine the search of an ethical system that provides answers to today’s complex moral problems.

*At various places in this book, the generic term man is used. This term refers to women, men and children.


Edited by Mega X.exe on September 27, 2006 at 18:46:23.

God
Chris Ray Gun is still cool
Offline
860 posts
Quote

I think our rules for ethcal treatment should be absed on whether or not the subject can think. For example, if you kill a dog, you should get a (legal) punishment for killing a dog, not a man, but if you killed this monkey-like thing, it should be treated as an animal if it thinks like an animal, or like a human if it is sentient.

Edited by God on September 28, 2006 at 12:30:18.

RisingDragon
Goat Herder
Inactive
-4295 post
Lilly Satou
Lilly Satou
Acquired on 2 April 2012
Emi Ibarazaki
Emi Ibarazaki
Acquired on 2 April 2012
Pyro
Pyro
Acquired on 2 April 2012
Heavy
Heavy
Acquired on 2 April 2012
Demoman
Demoman
Acquired on 2 April 2012

... and 18 more
Quote

But how can you tell if it's sentient? Many animals are sentient... monkeys, dolphins, whales, etc. They'll display behaviors quite different from humans for the most part, but still have sentience.

It's things like this that makes me fight my parents to prevent myself integration into society. >.>


"Why do you care that I care that you care enough to care that I care for caring?" "Conversation isn't your strong point, is it?"
"I worship the supreme comrade Cossack!"
"OugharagarraaahhHHH: When 'Ow' just won't cut it."
ImageImage
Image

CAPCOM: We put the "No" in Innovation.

Morphman
Niz-Da
Offline
2647 posts
Quote

A baby is sentient, but it cannot protest against being done harm. Same goes for many of the 'higher', further evolved species of animals, such as dogs and dolphins.

So we are now allowed to simply go out an kill babies and get the same punishment we would get as if we killed a dog?


Image
All hail the Supreme Comrade Cossack!

Samsara
Superstar!
Offline
4039 posts
Quote

Exactly. Unless you can get into an animals mind, you have no idea whether or not the animal can think. Dogs can work things out, they can reason, they learn, what is to say they can't think, feel and know?

Edited by Samsara on September 28, 2006 at 18:50:04.


God
Chris Ray Gun is still cool
Offline
860 posts
Quote

Because it is obvious from their behavior that they cannot lean more then repitition (what the average person would call 'training'). They cannot analyze and use logic. They have actually already begun to study the way the human brain thinks by looking at it scientifically (they have made connection which proves how and where thinking is done, in some instances). They can do the same thing for other animals if it ever becomes nessecery.

As a second-type subject, it may be wrong to kill any type of animal, but we hve to keep it in perspective as to how our species in general will see it. There will never come a time when a human is sentenced to life imprisonment, death, or torture for killling a non-specific ant, and if you think that killing a dog should be punished the same way as killing a human, doesn't that also mean that the dog should go to prison for what it kills as well?

I was thinking of dolphins while writing this example. They are an example of an animal which we are not sure to what level they can function. Monekys, however, I am not sure about, because they seem to be of a lower capacity then you imply, IMO. But I am not a scientist, behavorist, etc. Other primates such as gorillas, however, may be higher.

Edited by God on September 29, 2006 at 14:54:57.

Morphman
Niz-Da
Offline
2647 posts
Quote

Scientist #1: "We cannot understand the mind as it is now."

Scientist #2: "Also, were it simpler, we still would not."

Student: "Why is that?"

Scientist #2: *smacks Student* "Because humans would be stupid!"


Image
All hail the Supreme Comrade Cossack!