Which in itself is an irony that, I actually find to be a very well done thing on Lucas\'s part.

[Edited on 5/29/2005 by Mega X.exe]

Yes, he did that very well.

A few posts back, someone mentioned seeing the Millenium Falcon... Yup, it\'s there! It\'s a bit of a cookie, really. As for all the Jedi dying in three minutes... it was a surprise attack by their own forces, and it happened so fast, because it was all supposed to be instantanious... Of course, I can also argue the other way and say, \"If they\'re all Jedi, then why couldn\'t they sense this oncoming betrayal?\" On another minor plothole note, it amused me to decide that there\'s no way that Anakin and Obi-Wan could have fought like that on a volcanic planet with no extra breating apparatus... do you have any idea how much poison gas even one Volcano expels? XD They weren\'t even coughing! lol. Don\'t get me wrong, I\'m a huge fan of the movie, but I have this tendancy to pick things apart when I think too much...

-Ri

I really kind of liked the dark feel of the movie. It was a very nice way to set the heroic tone of the first 3, er, the last 3. I guess it would have helped if they\'d been in order, not that it\'s a problem this way.

I noticed 2 funny things throughout the trilogy:
1. Did you notice how many people get their hands cut off throughout Star Wars? Luke Skywalker, Anakin, that guy in the bar in one of the original Star Wars, and

Yeah, you\'re right about the second, Samsara; I guess I just wasn\'t thinking. As for the other... yes he does. He wouldn\'t have been standing there screaming if it were just his lightsaber! (I\'ve got a roomful of Starwars junkies here telling me this, too. But I guess the only way to know for sure is to find something official. Maybe I should read the bloody book.)

-Ri

He\'s standing there screaming because he\'s being zapped by palpatine. i don\'t care how many nerds you\'ve got there feeding you the answers, I saw it on Saturday and I don\'t forget things like that.

Samsara... one of those \"nerds\" is my fiance. There\'s no reason to get like that because I said that I\'d have to check something official. I didn\'t personally attack you or your friends; don\'t attack mine.

-Ri

Whoa! I didn\'t think you\'d take it so personally! Sorry! It\'s just the way it came out in your post: I have a lot of star wars junkies telling me....

I\'m just talking about the film and you can\'t get much more official then that.

I have not seen this movie, but it also says on Wikipedia that Windu\'s hand is severed.

Ah, I must have accidentally hit Quote instead of edit. Sorry about that.

[Edited on 5/30/05 by Mr.Mettaur]

His hand did get cut off. I know it did. As for the saber I can\'t remember it being in two pieces. Shouldn\'t we put this in spoilers? Doesn\'t matter, people read it anyway.

His hand was cut off. ITs kind of hard to kill someone when your hand just got cut off and your lightsaber flew out the window. And I would havecut off Anakin\'s head. I would\'ve been like, hmmm, maybe he isn\'t dead yet. Just for good measure SLICE!

Yeah, I thought Mace\'s saber dropped out of the window....But then again, it was a 10:00 movie.....^_^

I saw it a 6:00 so I\'d remember most of it, and this part is very vivid in my memory. Anakin cut the front part of Windu\'s lightsabre off (leaving his arm attached), when he get caught off and from that point, the Jedi\'s power went quite literally out of the window.

I\'m pretty sure I saw an arm get cut off.

I saw it 12:00 yesterday. he wouldn\'t be screaming in pain if his hand wasn\'t cut off, he\'d be punching the hell out of The dude.

Whilst being zapped by Palpatine and being thrown out of a window? Nice logic, there.

So much for spoiler Tags...

\"GAH!!!!!!!!!!! You killed Herald!\" - Reply from Windu if his lightsaber was the only thing cut off.

Hands cut off, secret ships, easter eggs....The green alien in the backround that looks like george lucas...

I watched it on friday I have no questions it was cool!

It looks like we\'ll only be able settle this when the DVD comes out.

His hand came off. We know this for sure. I watched it in my own home. I borrowed a pirate copy off a friend. Damned lightsaber.

Hmm...Anakin cuts Mace\'s hand, then Palpatine shocks him. Either that part got taken out of the UK release (which I highly doubt) or someone played some Jedi mind tricks on you <<;...besides, Windu wasn\'t screaming when he got shocked. He screamed before.

I definitely remember the lightsabre landing on the floor in two parts.

Er... whether Windu lost his hand before he died or not, isn\'t it about time to stop arguing about it? I have a feeling that no matter how forceful anyone is, we\'re not changing anyone else\'s opinion. *Sighs and regrets ever mentioning it in the first place*

-Ri

Hand was cut.

Go buy the book, silly!

Seriously, his hand got cut off, how could Anikin and the Emporer and Anikin were talking for ten sec...that was funny and jacked-up...